Are effective managers and leaders born or made? Discussing the Debate

Are effective managers and leaders born or made? Discussing the Debate

As a leader, you’re responsible for setting the tone and direction of your team – and, ultimately, your organization. It’s your job to motivate and encourage them to achieve their goals while keeping them safe and healthy. But what are the essential qualities of a successful leader? In this blog post, we’ll explore this question in-depth and discuss the leadership traits that make a manager successful. Whether you’re new to leadership or a seasoned professional, read about the skills you need to be a successful leader!

What is Leadership?

In its most straightforward meaning, effective leadership stands for the ability of an individual to influence others in progress toward a shared goal. Leaders need to acutely understand their people and circumstances to guide others throughout the journey. It also helps them efficiently utilize the resources available at their disposal, including the people. Leadership does not end with showing the way. As John Maxwell famously noted “A leader is one who knows the way, goes the way, and shows the way.” The leader does not merely guide by also exemplifies. Great leaders lead by example. They demonstrate the ethics that they wish to cherish in their team. Moreover, they adopt a hands-on approach and coach their team to overcome limitations and reach new heights by using motivation and innovation appropriately. The job of a leader is manifold, and sometimes they have to turn into coaches while the other time they have to use their impeccable management skills. While discussing leadership, we also note that certain traits are common to all leaders. This understanding had a historical basis when it was assumed that leaders could only be born and not made out of people like us.

Are Managers and Leaders Born or Made?

The debate is ancient – so what’s the answer? Traditionally, it was believed that leaders are born. Examples of many leaders were taken to show that they demonstrated the signs of greatness right from childhood. Certain traits of individuals, such as confidence and heroism – set them apart from the rest of the people as potential leaders. However, leaders who rose from poverty and innumerable challenges have tested such notions. But over time, such opinions have died down. Thus, we do not consider evidence of leadership traits since childhood necessary for a leader! Research has shown that leaders are largely made. Leadership is not about genetic factors but also accounts for learnings from the environment. The belief that leaders are made from hard work and experience has gained substantial support. The University of Illinois has also demonstrated that training can mold individuals into leaders and help in developing leadership traits. Thus, the actual answer lies somewhere in the middle, and a person might inherit some leadership qualities and learn the rest from the world to grow into an effective leader. It means that organizations can develop leadership skills in their in-house talent and develop leaders at home!

Let’s look at some examples – we see leaders developing everyday in front of us

  • Personal Growth: A shy and introverted individual gradually develops strong leadership skills through experiences and self-improvement. Over time, they learn to communicate effectively, motivate others, and make decisions confidently, evolving into an influential leader.
  • Learning from Failures: A manager faces multiple setbacks in their career but uses each failure as a learning opportunity. Through reflection, adapting strategies, and seeking mentorship, they build resilience and refine their leadership abilities, ultimately becoming a respected figure in their organization.
  • Skill Development: An employee with no prior leadership experience joins a leadership development program. Through training, workshops, and mentorship, they acquire essential leadership skills like delegation, conflict resolution, and team motivation. Over time, they transform into a capable and inspiring leader.
  • Adapting to Change: An employee is promoted to a leadership role during a period of organizational change. Despite feeling overwhelmed initially, they actively seek guidance, learn to manage uncertainty, and gradually gain the confidence and skills needed to lead their team through transitions successfully.
  • Inspired by Role Models: A person observes their mentors’ leadership qualities and is inspired to develop similar attributes. They focus on improving their communication, empathy, and strategic thinking, honing these skills over time and emerging as an effective leader themselves.
To become a successful leader, you can focus on developing the skills required for effective leadership. Let us understand in greater detail what these skills are.

What Is A Successful Leader?

So what qualities are essential for a leader to be successful? There is no clear answer to this question. But a few qualities are said to be shared in all effective leaders. Typically, these primarily include the ability to influence and motivate their teams to keep going forward in pursuit of the goal. The leader needs to be sure of their purpose and path to take the team ahead and help them cross hurdles. In this process, a leader needs the help of many leadership skills. For instance, taking the team through challenges will require the leader to possess impeccable communication skills. It will help them avoid misunderstandings and solve problems arising from miscommunication. But suppose an issue does arise; what happens then? The leader’s conflict resolution skills come to save the day. In the furor of chaos, time slips away quietly. A leader needs practical time management skills to keep hold of their schedules. They also need to learn how to set and achieve smart goals with their teams. Through this journey, the team is bound to face multiple challenges, often leaving them amazed. To outsmart these difficulties, leaders must facilitate collaboration and innovation in their teams. And while at it, they need to give constructive feedback to their team to correct their path as they keep moving ahead. That sounds like a lot! Leadership is not merely about carrying out a few functions. In totality, leadership stands for a mindset. The leadership mindset is a growth mindset that emphasizes constant growth and development for the team ad the team members. Developing a growth mindset is among the crucial challenges that leaders face. Successful leadership helps their team grow and develop over time as individuals and professionally by offering ample opportunities and inspiring them with their vision.

What are Leadership Traits or Qualities?

While there is no clear definition of indispensable leadership traits or skills. We understand that a few leadership qualities are essential to fulfilling the role of a leader. These qualities help individuals become one step over mere managers. People who build these qualities learn to influence and guide teams in their desired directions. For starters, a leader needs to value integrity. Having integrity as one of their core values helps leaders set standards for behavior in their teams. Ideas based on truth and trustworthiness also assist in establishing credibility and creating mutual respect in which teams can operate. Another quality that greatly helps leaders is humility. Great leaders are willing to accept mistakes and consequences. They do not try to shift the blame onto others. Instead, they focus on the greatest good and empower others to take ownership of their work. Along with these, a few other leadership traits help managers adapt to the role effectively. You can read more about them here.

How can you become a leader?

There is no definite answer to this question. While some people might be born with leadership traits, most skills a leader needs can be learned. It means that you can develop leadership skills on your own. You can start by developing a good work ethic. As you grow as an individual, you will learn to understand and respect the needs of others. It is essential in leading effective teams. Make sure that your communication skills are up to par too. Leaders must communicate effectively with their teammates, superiors, and other stakeholders if they want their plan to be successful. Additionally, influential leaders know how to get things done without compromising ethics or principles, so teamwork is always valued. There are many paths to leadership development. These include: You can read more about all of these to pick the suitable one for you. However, most of these methods of developing leadership skills are accompanied by their own sets of limitations. For instance, if you pick up self-help methods, you might find yourself lost in the absence of guidance. On the other hand, leadership workshops and seminars may be insufficient as they offer general insights. Your challenges could be entirely different! Therefore, you need to pick the right option very smartly. You can also take up the AI-enabled leadership coaching platform Risely. Risely offers real-time support for your challenges as you wish. It allows you to pick your challenges and progress at your own pace. Adding well-researched content designed as toolkits and self-assessments is a great benefit. The ability to access it from anywhere at any time at an affordable price makes it an ideal pick for up-and-coming leaders of the new generation – who overcome limitations to rise rapidly! Find out more about AI co-pilot for leadership development here: Becoming The Best Manager: Why AI Co-Pilot Overtakes Manual Solutions?

Conclusion

Leadership is the buzzword of today’s age. Yet, there’s a lot of confusion surrounding it. In this blog, we understood that leaders could be made with adequate guidance. Nonetheless, the old debate of are leaders born or made is sure to continue raging. The emphasis has now moved from leadership traits to skills. Leadership skills are essential and can be developed in many ways. The best way to find the right method for you is to talk to others who have done it before, read about leadership development methods, and then decide on an approach that fits your personality and goals.

Never stop growing with the free growth mindset toolkit for managers.

Get the free growth mindset toolkit for managers to gain insights and access frameworks that create your journey to continuous learning.


FAQs

Why managers are made and not born?

Managers are made and not born because they managerial skills which are the mark of effective managers can be learned. With sufficient practice and right resources such as toolkits and assessments, managers can learn leadership skills and become effective.

Is a good and effective manager inherited or acquired?

Effective management skills are a combination of both personal qualities and professional training. Managerial skills can be acquired through the various modes of training available such as managerial training programs, leadership coaching, etc.

What makes an effective manager and leader?

An effective manager and leader is one who can guide their team in the right direction. They have the right skills such as communication and conflict resolution to overcome internal team challenges as well as other traits such as active listening, problem solving, critical thinking, etc. to maneuver the team through challenges.

Other Related Blogs

The Psychology Of Managers: 6 Areas You Need To Know

The Psychology Of Managers: 6 Areas You Need To Know What goes on in the mind of a manager? That’s an interesting question with many answers to follow. In this…

7 Must Watch Podcasts For Managers On Their First Job

Don’t miss these 7 podcasts for managers in your first stint Are you excited about being a manager for the first time? Or is some fear tugging slightly as you…

4 Major Management Styles And How To Ace All

4 Major Management Styles And How To Ace All Effective management skills are essential for success in any organization. Managers are crucial in guiding and supporting their teams to achieve…

Strategic Thinking Training For Leaders Simplified

Strategic Thinking Training For Leaders Simplified Strategic thinking is a vital skill for business leaders, managers, and employees in today’s fast-paced, competitive world. It goes beyond day-to-day tasks and involves…

What Makes A Great Manager Stand Out? 10 Traits Of Great Managers

What Makes A Great Manager Stand Out? 10 Traits Of Great Managers

As a manager, it’s your job to lead and effectively manage your team. Good managers can carry out these responsibilities considerably and achieve their targets. But what makes a great manager better than a good manager? In this blog post, we’ll talk about the ten traits of great managers that help them win. From being able to stay calm under pressure to inspiring and motivating others, some extraordinary traits make a manager great. These traits are something every manager should strive for. So read on and learn the ins and outs of becoming a great manager.

What Is A Good Manager?

A good manager handles the day-to-day business operations while maintaining a positive outlook. They can delegate tasks efficiently and communicate effectively with their team. Additionally, good managers can set goals and benchmarks and keep track of progress. They also know when to give feedback, step back, and let their team operate autonomously. Above all, good managers can build trust and respect among their team members. But, still, good managers cannot reach the highest potential managerial effectiveness. They are good at managing teams but not great or the best manager, which is a significant gap or difference. So, what do great managers do differently? Let’s figure it out in our next section.

What Makes A Great Manager Different?

A few traits set a great manager apart from good managers. Great managers can motivate and inspire their teams. They possess excellent management skills and a deep understanding of their team’s strengths and weaknesses. They have mastered the art of handling multiple tasks and streamlining various processes smoothly. A great manager knows how to tap into their team’s potential and helps them realize their vision. They know how to handle any possible situation, and if not, they know how to face new challenges calmly. Great managers build consensus among their team members while saving them from the chaos that conflicts can invite. How are they able to do so? Several traits of great managers make them significantly different and better than good managers. What are the qualities of great managers? Let’s unfold that in our next section.

10 Traits Of Great Managers That Summon Success

1. Inspiring and motivating others

Good managers can make their teams work. But a great manager gets things done like a boss with their teams. The difference lies in their ability to inspire and motivate their teams. A great manager can not only efficiently run operations but also inspire and motivate others, often by setting an example themselves. Their ability to encourage employee activity comes from clarity in vision and an action plan. Communication skills that help in sharing and receiving ideas add to it. As a result, they can build trust and command respect among their team members. Further, they are not shy to accept mistakes and offer due praise.

2. Thinking strategically

Good managers are usually more tactical than strategic. They focus on the here and now and on what needs to be done to get the job done. A great manager, on the other hand, is more strategic. They think about the vision and envisage plans to achieve those goals. They are also capable of keenly analyzing their environment and plan their moves accordingly. While both types of managers are essential, a great manager is more likely to succeed in the long run and become a great leader.

3. Making decisions quickly and confidently

A good manager is someone who has adequate decision-making ability. You can find them making decisions and implementing them effectively in day-to-day business. They can do this due to their experience and availability of information. Yet, in some instances, you might find them bewildered. Frequent and abrupt changes might throw a good manager off kilter. A great manager, on the other hand, overcomes unanticipated challenges. They make decisions quickly and confidently, even under uncertain situations. It is because they not only can gather and process information quickly, but they also dare to act in the face of uncertainty. Great managers lead their teams through ambiguity on a clear path.

4. Building and maintaining relationships

Good managers are good at managing people, but great managers are great at building and maintaining relationships. Great managers create harmony and balance in their workplaces and connect with their employees on a personal level. They show empathy and understand that people are different, which is why they can work with them in a way that meets their needs and makes them productive. In consequence, great managers can coach their employees into better professionals and future leaders by bringing out their potential. Team members who work with great managers enjoy lasting relationships long after they stop actively working with each other. The team members always look up to their managers for guidance across their careers.

5. Communicating effectively

For a manager to be effective, assertive and clear communication is vital. They facilitate the best team meetings and even one-on-one meetings with their teammates. It means being able to communicate clearly and concisely, as well as being able to listen to and understand what others are saying. Good managers often miss active listening and then fail to build emotional connections with their teams, but great managers never miss a beat. They are proactive in planning and communicating the most critical and trivial information. They also know how to handle sensitive communication with care. They can handle exit conversations, negative news, uncertain or volatile situations, with empathy and respect.

6. Delegating and empowering others

A good manager believes in having a close check on and reasonable control of the work within their team. However, they might fall into the habit of micromanagement while running after efficiency. A great manager, on the other hand, believes in giving autonomy and empowering their team. Thus, great managers can cultivate ownership and help their teammates grow while focusing on strategic aspects of work. Their delegation skills are significantly better than good managers. It is because they have a better understanding of the strengths and weaknesses of their team members, which allows them to make better decisions about what tasks should be delegated to whom. They can set clear expectations and provide straightforward instructions, which helps avoid misunderstandings.

7. Leading by example

Great managers are better able to lead by example. Good managers usually try to lead by explaining their expectations from team members. They expect certain behaviors from their team and try to maintain managerial standards. But this is not always successful. Great managers model the behaviors and hard work they want their team members to exhibit. This way, they can better manage the team and ensure their employees have practical knowledge of what exactly they need to follow. Moreover, with a hands-on approach, these managers can better understand and connect with their teams. As a result, they are decisive, transparent, and supportive. These qualities of great managers put them above a good manager.

8. Coaching and developing others

Good managers are content with their lives and are happy with what they have since their current work is being done effectively. They don’t see much need for coaching to develop their team if the team is consistently meeting the targets. On the other hand, great managers are constantly looking for ways to improve and help their team members grow. They look for new competencies and qualities that their team can develop and then facilitate through professional development and training programs. They are patient and understanding and have the know-how to coach and develop others. Great managers have a growth mindset and a strong sense of purpose and are driven by their goals.

9. Handling difficult conversations

Great managers can better handle difficult conversations and people in a way that leads to a productive outcome. They know how to listen attentively and understand the other person’s point of view. It allows them to devise a fair and beneficial solution for both parties. Good managers, on the other hand, aren’t as good at handling challenging conversations. It is because they often rush into decisions without fully understanding the situation. They might even hesitate and avoid some conversations. As a result, they make decisions that are not well-received by either party involved.

10. Staying calm under pressure

Staying calm under pressure is one of the most required essential of a manager. A great manager is better equipped to remain calm when a situation arises where the good manager is under pressure. Good managers manage stressful situations well, but great managers become stronger from such situations. They understand that mistakes are part of the learning process and that stress will not catalyze them into making the best decision. They know how to help their teams understand the gravity of the errors and handle disappointment at work. Ultimately, great managers are masters of balance and know how to use it wisely.

Conclusion

A great manager can balance work and personal life well, is good at problem-solving, and possesses the ten traits listed above. By understanding what makes a great manager better than a good manager, you can develop the skills and traits needed to be a great manager. It will help you ensure that you make the best out of the team and that you come out as a great and effective leader from whom the team follows and takes inspiration.

Delegate effectively and become a good manager.

Download the free effective delegation toolkit to start smart delegation in your teams today.

Other Related Blogs

Know these 9 Basic Roles in Coaching as a Leader

Know these 9 Basic Roles in Coaching as a Leader As an L&D leader, your role isn’t just about guiding your teams; it’s also about spotting underlying issues in team…

How Evidence-Based Coaching and Its Models Empower Leaders?

How Evidence-Based Coaching Models Empower Leaders? Imagine going on a coaching journey where every decision, every insight, and each strategy had at its core some research. That is the very…

5 Unique Benefits Of Online Leadership Coaching

5 Unique Benefits Of Online Leadership Coaching Remember the days of leadership development being confined to a stuffy conference room filled with flipcharts and generic advice? Yeah, those days are…

5 Secrets To Ace Project Manager Training

5 Secrets To Ace Project Manager Training You’ve poured your heart and soul into building a dream team. You’ve recruited talented individuals with diverse skill sets, and you’re confident they…
Exit mobile version